This is a little research I did last year when a certain Athletic Director from Nebraska (Steve Pederson) tried to explain why the Huskers were not always going to be on top like we were in the 90's. Thank goodness Tom and Bo are back to show, not only Nebraska, but the rest of college football that we CAN and WILL be a power football team once again.
Let me set the foundation first.
I looked at all of the teams that finished the year in the top 20 according to the AP poll (except in 1960's, had to use the coaches' poll as AP only ranked the top 10) starting in 1960 through last year.
Teams that ranked in the top 20 at least once per decade:
(1960-1969) 64 teams
(1970-1979) 54 teams
(1980-1989) 51 teams
(1990-1999) 57 teams
(2000-2006) 53 teams (and counting)
Of the 64 teams in the 1960's, (17) seventeen of them had at least 5 appearances in the top 20 including:
Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Arkansas, Ohio State, Alabama, Michigan State, Penn State, Syracuse, Purdue, Texas, UCLA, USC, Oregon State, Nebraska, Notre Dame and Tennessee.
Of these (17) seventeen schools, only 4 remained consistant through 1999:
Ohio State 8 top 20 finishes in the 70's
7 in the 80's
7 in the 90's
Alabama 9 top 20 finishes in the 70's
7 in the 80's
6 in the 90's
Penn State 9 top 20 finishes in the 70's
6 in the 80's
9 in the 90's
Nebraska 10 top 20 finishes in the 70's
10 in the 80's
9 in the 90's
With teams like Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Michigan State, Syracuse, Purdue and Oregon State dropping out of the "power" ranks (not having 5 or more years ranked in each of the next 3 decades 70's, 80's and 90's) that left room for other teams to emerge.
The 70's saw new comers Arizona State, Michigan, Auburn, Houston, Oklahoma and Maryland enter the ranks of at least 5 years ranked in the 70's. These 6 teams basically took the place of the 7 that dropped out (from whatever reason) in the 60's.
(3) three of these teams have consistantly been near the top in the remaining decades:
Michigan 10 top 20 finishes in the 70's
8 in the 80's
9 in the 90's
Auburn 5 top 20 finishes in the 70's
7 in the 80's
Oklahoma 10 top 20 finishes in the 70's
8 in the 80's
Although both Auburn and Oklahoma did not have 5 or more seasons in the 90's ranked in the top 20, they are both back in the current decade with over 5, Auburn (5) and Oklahoma (6).
The 1980's is where we saw the greatest number of new teams enter as possible future powers. All we ranked in the top 20 at least 5 of the 10 years:
Georgia, Pittsburgh, Florida State, BYU, Washington, Miami, SMU, Clemson, Iowa and LSU. (4) of these teams (Georgia, Flordia State, Washington and Miami) remained near the top in the 1990's. Miami, Georgia and the resurgent LSU squads each have 5 top 20 finishes this decade.
The 90's saw teams like Colorado (7 top 20 finish seasons), Florida (10 top 20 finish seasons), Texas A&M (8 top 20 finish seasons) and Kansas State (7 top 20 finish seasons).
2 out of the 4 additional powers in the 90's were opponents of Nebraska on a regular basis. Throughout the 90's, Nebraska not only had Oklahoma on their minds, but now had to contend with Colorado and Kansas State who were on the rise. Did that affect Nebraska? Hardly, only 3 national titles and a very impressive streak of 60-3.
Pittsburgh - interesting school to pick right? 5 times in the 80's Pitt finished in the top 20. 1989 Pitt was ranked 17th at the end of the year. In the past 17 years, they have ranked in the top 20 only 1 time since then, in 2002 they finished the year 19th.
Of the "power" programs over the last 4 decades, Ohio State is currently ranked 4th, Alabama (under new leadership) is currently unranked, Penn State is unranked, Nebraska is ranked 25th, Michigan is unranked, Auburn is unranked and Oklahoma is ranked 10th.
Every year and sometimes for a stretch of 3 years, teams come into the top 20 and then just like they came in, they drop out. Parity? Hardly. More like factors of a good recruiting year, excellent high school seniors, etc. All these play into teams having a good run. But the powers of college football, those that can consistently find a way to win, can overcome the ever changing game of college football.
Oh, this decade, there is only one team that has 5 or more seasons in the top 20 - Virginia Tech.
Nebraska - Once a team rich in power, now searching for a new identity.
Parity did not hit Nebraska like it did other schools. Parity hit Nebraska the day Steve Pederson announced that Frank Solich would no longer lead the Nebraska football team and that the team needed new leadership and direction to take them into the future.
NDHusker